Route GuidesRoutes City GuidesCities Map Log in
Write a new posting

Latest journeys

Cann to Westminister by Cong Wang
Froidthier by Vincent Smekens
60m loop by StuH
lennoxtown-strathblane-st mocha by Alice Bates
ashfod by gonk
herons park by gonk
margate by gonk
Christian by Greg Stanley
canti by gonk
ardeche_montagne by Nathanaël Schaeffer

Become a supporter

New off-road cycle track hardly used in route planning

We have a new off-road cycle track with a good surface in Durham, mostly shared with pedestrians but some segregation. It is now taken account of in your routing data because I was able to plan a route which uses it:

https://cycle.travel/map/journey/190535

However, cycle.travel does seem to prefer using the main roads, which have no cycle infrastructure to speak of, and which, despite being 30mph limits, have speeding drivers on. What can I do in OpenStreetMap to improve the tagging in a way which will get this cycle track to be recommended more? Or perhaps the roads need tagging somehow to indicate how hostile they are?

Here are two examples, still going to the same destination, where the new cycle track is not used:

https://cycle.travel/map/journey/190534

In this one, Mill Hill Lane is reasonably quiet, but the other roads are not. The turning from Elvet Hill Road into Potters Bank is a nasty junction on a blind bend. I'd have thought for most people the new cycle track would be better.

https://cycle.travel/map/journey/190532

In this route there is perhaps more of an distance penalty to using the new cycle track. The first stretch is on a narrow shared-use pavement, and then Potters Bank is a road where drivers frequently exceed 30mph because it has a rural appearance. Again, I would have thought that the new cycle track would be better for most users.

How should I be improving the tagging? Does the surface, width, etc. have an impact? Or is it just that the cycle track is shared with pedestrians, crosses lots of roads and wiggles about that makes the routing engine so reluctant to use it?

Page 1