Route GuidesRoutes City GuidesCities Map Log in

cycle.travel - thanks and anomolies

13 Mar 2023
by ndrew ☕
in forum cycle.travel
Find a better bike route. Try our map & route-planner »

Become a supporter

First, thank you Richard for an amazing resource, I have been using the site for a bit over a year, including riding most of the easy east coast LEJOG (I tweaked bits and rode Lizard / Cape Wrath).

Second, a few anomalies, may be useful for debugging etc. may be Open Streetmap issues beyond your control,  none of these seriously affect most rides so please feel free to ignore.

1. Access
- CT will take you to Cape Wrath, even though it is MOD and sometimes closed
- Will not let you go anywhere near Imber (Salisbury Plane, MOD, rarely open ) but I did ride there at new year
- Does allow you to plot a route to visit the Lions at Longleat - assume that security and common sense should avoid mishaps!

2. Hills
You mentioned you had tweaked hill routing in the recent news. It might have gone a fraction far? eg: It now routes up Whitehill in Bradford on Avon, rather than following the Wiltshire cycleway route. May suit some, but feels pretty hard work, worse than the theoretical 13% suggests. eg: https://cycle.travel/map/journey/403767

Andrew

Comments

Thu 16 Mar 2023, 14:33

Thanks!

Because cycle.travel’s routing engine isn’t time-sensitive (i.e. you can’t say “I’m planning to ride this on August 15th”) then it generally goes with OSM’s general assumption on whether a route is open or not. Hence it won’t ever let you go to Imber. The Cape Wrath road is an interesting one as it’s not explicitly tagged as military use in OSM - I’ll have a think if there’s anything that could be done there.

The lions look like a pure tagging error in OSM – it was marked as private motor car access but unrestricted for bikes! I’ve fixed that though annoyingly it’ll just miss the new c.t map update.

Whitehill looks like an interesting case – I’ll take a look.